Los Angeles Nannies

Pay and legal

The Hidden Costs of Paying a Nanny in Los Angeles

There are many routes to go down to find your perfect nanny, and like your nanny is a unique asset to your family that reflects your household’s needs, so too will be the journey to find them.

Quick Answer

There are many routes to go down to find your perfect nanny, and like your nanny is a unique asset to your family that reflects your household’s needs, so too will be the journey to find them.

The Hidden Costs of Paying Your Nanny Legally in Los Angeles

Hiring a nanny “on the books” in Los Angeles means more than just paying their hourly wage. Many first-time nanny employers are surprised to find a variety of additional costs and legal requirements that significantly increase the true cost of employing a nanny. From the difference between gross and net pay to payroll taxes, overtime, and insurance, the expenses can add up quickly. This post will explain these hidden costs in detail – using real numbers – and outline the relevant California and federal laws (as of 2025) so you can budget and comply with the law confidently.

Gross vs. Net Pay: Understanding the Difference

One of the first potential miscommunications when hiring a nanny is gross pay vs. net pay. Gross pay is the nanny’s earnings before taxes and withholdings, while net pay is their take-home pay after all deductions. Many nannies (especially those who have been paid “off the books” before) tend to think in terms of net take-home pay, whereas employers need to budget based on gross pay plus taxes. It’s crucial to clarify this during salary negotiations. If you and your nanny discuss a wage without specifying gross or net, you could end up with very different expectations.

Real Numbers Example: Let’s say you agree to pay your nanny $500 per week gross. Out of that $500, you (as the employer) will withhold the employee’s taxes – Social Security, Medicare, federal and state income tax – typically around $105 (this can vary based on withholding allowances). That leaves your nanny with roughly $395 net in take-home pay on a $500 gross paycheck. In addition, you must pay your own employer taxes on top of the $500, roughly another $63 in this example. In total, your $500 gross wage costs you about $563, and the nanny’s net pay is about $395.

Now imagine the nanny had asked for $500 net per week as their take-home pay. In that case, you would need to “gross-up” their pay. You’d end up paying about $645 gross to result in a $500 net after withholding taxes, and then add roughly $81 of employer taxes on top. Your total cost would be about $726 so that the nanny still receives $500 net. Compared to the earlier scenario, that’s an extra ~$163 per week to deliver the same take-home pay! This dramatic difference is why it’s vital to distinguish gross vs. net in your work agreement. As HomeWork Solutions notes, a net pay agreement means the employer is taking on all the employee’s tax burden – including income taxes – which greatly increases the family’s cost. Always state the agreed gross hourly wage in the contract to avoid confusion.

Employer Payroll Taxes and Obligations in California

When you pay a nanny legally, you become a household employer and assume several tax obligations often called the “nanny taxes.” In California and the U.S., these include:

Tax Thresholds: Note that these nanny tax obligations kick in at relatively low thresholds. If you pay your nanny $2,800 or more in a calendar year (2025 threshold), you are required to pay Social Security and Medicare taxes and issue a W-2. (This threshold is adjusted annually for inflation; it was $2,700 for 2024.) Similarly, if you pay $1,000 or more in any calendar quarter, you must pay FUTA unemployment taxes. Practically speaking, any regular nanny working even part-time will exceed these thresholds – for instance, $150/week crosses $2,800 in just 19 weeks. In short, if you’re employing a nanny in Los Angeles beyond a very casual occasional babysitter, you will be responsible for all these payroll taxes.

Bottom Line: In total, your share of payroll taxes will typically add approximately 10-12% on top of your nanny’s gross wages. (If your nanny’s wages are higher, the percentage might be a bit lower because unemployment taxes cap out.) For example, GTM Payroll notes that most families pay around 9-12% of wages in employer taxes. So if you pay a nanny $40,000 in gross wages, budget an extra ~$4,000+ in taxes. Later, we’ll see concrete case studies with these breakdowns.

Workers’ Compensation Insurance

Another “hidden” cost – often overlooked by new household employers – is workers’ compensation insurance for your nanny. In California, you are legally required to have a workers’ comp policy for your household employee in almost all cases. The only exception is if the person worked less than 52 hours and earned less than $100 in the 90 days before an injury – which would only apply to extremely occasional help. If your nanny is regular (even part-time), you must carry workers’ comp.

Workers’ compensation covers medical expenses and a portion of wages if your nanny gets injured or sick on the job. It protects both the worker and you (the employer) from the huge costs of workplace injuries. In fact, if you don’t have coverage and your nanny gets hurt while working, you could be liable for all their medical bills and lost wages, and face fines or lawsuits. Given the high risks, compliance is important.

Cost of Workers’ Comp: The cost of a policy for a nanny in California can vary. Fortunately, many homeowners insurance companies allow you to add a household employee endorsement to your home insurance. Often, this is the easiest and cheapest route. Some Los Angeles families report adding a rider for as little as $80-$100 per year through their homeowner’s policy. If your insurer doesn’t offer that, you may need a standalone workers’ comp policy. Standalone policies might cost on the order of a few hundred dollars per year. One source estimates about $600-$800 per year for a typical household workers’ comp policy. The premium usually depends on the nanny’s payroll and the insurer’s rate for the classification (nannies are considered domestic workers, a relatively low-risk category). Given the range, you’ll want to get a quote – but expect at least a few hundred dollars annually for this coverage. It’s a good idea to factor this into your budget from the start.

California law makes obtaining this insurance fairly straightforward. As noted, check with your homeowner’s insurance first – most will add the required coverage for a nominal fee. If not, California’s state compensation insurance fund or private agencies can issue a policy. Do not skip this – not only is it legally required, but it’s also your safety net against potentially devastating injury costs.

Overtime Rules for Nannies in California

Overtime can be a significant cost if your nanny works long hours. Both federal and California laws govern domestic worker overtime, and California has some unique rules. Here’s what Los Angeles employers need to know:

In summary, for a typical live-out nanny in Los Angeles: pay overtime for any hours over 9 in one day or over 40 in a week. Overtime hours must be paid at 1.5 times the regular hourly rate. Always keep a time log; you cannot circumvent overtime by paying a flat salary or “daily rate.” (GTM Payroll reminds employers that household employees must be paid hourly with overtime – you can’t just agree on a flat weekly salary to cover 50 hours, for example.) If your nanny’s schedule regularly exceeds these hour limits, this premium pay will noticeably increase your costs.

Overtime Pay Example: Suppose you pay your nanny $20/hour base rate. If they work 50 hours in a week, that’s 10 hours of overtime. Those 10 OT hours must be paid at $30/hour (1.5x $20). So the week’s pay would be 40 hours × $20 + 10 hours × $30 = $800 + $300 = $1,100. Had you not accounted for OT, you might think 50 hours at $20 is $1,000 – but legally you owe an extra $100 in this scenario. Multiply that by a month or a year, and it’s substantial.

California and Los Angeles Labor Laws: Minimum Wage, Sick Leave, and More

Legally employing a nanny in L.A. also means you need to comply with general labor laws that cover domestic workers:

Now that we’ve covered the obligations, let’s look at a few concrete case studies to illustrate the full financial picture of different nanny scenarios in Los Angeles.

Case Studies: What Does a Nanny Really Cost?

Every family’s situation is different. You might hire a part-time nanny or a full-time nanny working overtime. You might agree on a higher hourly wage for fewer hours, or vice versa. Below are a few scenarios with cost breakdowns to show the all-in costs to you as the employer. In each case, we’ll assume the nanny is single with standard tax withholdings (no special exemptions), and we’ll include employer taxes, workers’ comp, and other obligations we discussed. These examples assume the family handles payroll legally and the nanny is classified as an employee (which they should be).

(These simple numbers are to understand the various rates that exist, these dollar values are below what our nannies are looking to be paid per hour – see our Honest House Promise)

Note: These case studies use 2025 tax rates (Social Security 6.2%, Medicare 1.45%, FUTA 0.6% up to $7k, CA SUI 3.4% up to $7k, etc.) and assume the nanny uses their full sick leave entitlement (which is a cost in that you pay wages even when they take sick days). We’ll also include an approximate cost for workers’ comp insurance.

Case Study 1: Part-Time Nanny (20 hours/week at $25/hour)

Scenario: A family hires a nanny for 20 hours per week, at a gross hourly rate of $25. The schedule is Monday-Friday 1pm-5pm (4 hours each day). There is no overtime, since the nanny never works over 9 hours in a day or 40 in a week.

Now, let’s break down the employer’s costs on top of the wages:

Cost ItemAnnual CostNotes
Nanny’s Gross Wages$26,000(This is the base salary for 20 hrs/week)
Employer FICA (Social Security & Medicare)$1,989

7.65% of $26,000

Federal Unemployment (FUTA)$42

0.6% on first $7,000

CA Unemployment (SUI @ 3.4% + ETT)$245

3.4% + 0.1% on first $7,000

Workers’ Comp Insurance~$200(Estimated – could be ~$100-$300 range)
Paid Sick Leave~$480(Coverage of 6 sick days at $25/hr)
Payroll Service Fees (optional)~$600(If using a service, e.g. ~$50/month)
****
Total Annual Cost (Employer)~$28,500(Not including optional payroll service)

In this part-time scenario, the family’s total cost is roughly $28.5k for the year, compared to the nanny’s gross earnings of $26k and the nanny’s net (take-home) pay of around $22k (after the nanny’s own taxes). The “hidden” overhead is on the order of 10-12%. Note that the sick leave cost is shown assuming the nanny uses their entitled 6 days; if they don’t use all of it, you wouldn’t actually pay those hours (but you should be prepared for it). If the family uses a payroll service, that adds another ~$600 per year in fees, but it saves a lot of time – which might be worth it, considering the IRS estimates household employers spend 60 hours/year on tax compliance if doing it themselves.

Case Study 2: Full-Time Nanny (45 hours/week at $20/hour)

Scenario: A family hires a nanny full-time, and the schedule is 9 hours per day, Monday-Friday (for example, 8am-5pm, with an hour lunch break covered by the parents – effectively 9 hours of work each day). The agreed gross pay rate is $20/hour. Overtime: The nanny works 45 hours in a week, which is 5 hours above 40, so those 5 hours must be paid at time-and-a-half. (Daily, they work 9 hours which does not exceed California’s 9-hour daily limit; however, federal law requires OT pay for the 41st-45th hours of the week.)

Cost breakdown for the employer:

Cost ItemAnnual CostNotes
Nanny’s Gross Wages$49,400(Includes ~$47,840 straight time + ~$1,560 overtime)
Employer FICA (Social Security & Medicare)$3,778

7.65% of $49,400

Federal Unemployment (FUTA)$42

0.6% on first $7,000 (max $42)

CA Unemployment (SUI + ETT)$245

3.5% on first $7,000 (max ~$245)

Workers’ Comp Insurance~$500(Estimated higher due to higher wage & full-time)
Paid Sick Leave~$800(5 days of sick leave at 9 hrs/day × $20)
Overtime PremiumIncluded above(Overtime wages are already included in gross $49.4k)
Payroll Service Fees (optional)~$600(If using service for payroll & taxes)
****
Total Annual Cost (Employer)~$54,800(Approx. $54.2k without payroll service fees)

In this full-time case, the family’s out-of-pocket cost is about $54,000-$55,000 for the year (not including the convenience of a payroll service). The nanny’s take-home pay would be roughly $40,000 after their taxes in this scenario, so again the employer’s total cost is about 35% higher than the nanny’s net pay. Notice that the overtime contributed an extra $1,560 to the gross wages for the year – not a huge fraction of the total, but certainly a cost to plan for. If the family had tried to circumvent overtime by paying a flat salary (say $950/week salary), they would still legally owe the overtime differentiation – so it’s simpler to think in terms of hourly pay as we’ve done.

Also, recall that at this pay level, the family may be able to offset some costs through tax benefits. For instance, if they have access to a Dependent Care FSA, they could pay $5,000 of the nanny’s wages with pre-tax dollars, saving perhaps $1,500 in taxes. They may also be eligible for the federal Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit on a portion of the childcare expenses. These can somewhat reduce the net cost of a nanny to the family (essentially government subsidies to encourage paying for childcare legally). It’s wise to consult a CPA or use resources from a nanny payroll provider to maximize these benefits.

Case Study 3: Overtime-Heavy Schedule (50 hours/week at $18/hour)


Scenario:
A family with demanding jobs has a nanny for 50 hours per week. Suppose they agree on an hourly rate of $18. The schedule might be 10 hours a day, Monday-Friday. This schedule does incur overtime: 10 hours each day means 1 hour of OT per day (beyond 9) under CA law, and in total 50 hours means 10 OT hours per week (beyond 40) under federal law – those actually overlap; effectively hours 41-50 in the week are overtime. All overtime hours are paid at 1.5 × $18 = $27/hour.

Cost breakdown:

Cost ItemAnnual CostNotes
Nanny’s Gross Wages$51,480(Includes overtime pay)
Employer FICA (Social Security & Medicare)$3,939

7.65% of $51,480

Federal Unemployment (FUTA)$42

(0.6% of first $7k)

CA Unemployment (SUI + ETT)$245

(3.5% of first $7k)

Workers’ Comp Insurance~$600(Higher payroll and more hours -> higher premium)
Paid Sick Leave~$864(Assuming 48 hours sick leave used at $18)
Overtime PremiumIncluded above(OT wages included in gross $51.48k)
Payroll Service Fees (optional)~$600(if using one)
****
Total Annual Cost (Employer)~$57,200(Approx. $56,600 without payroll service)

In this overtime-heavy scenario, the family’s total cost is about $56k-$57k for the year, whereas the nanny’s net take-home pay would be on the order of ~$42k. The lower base hourly rate ($18) is partially offset by the fact that 10 of those hours every week are paid at time-and-a-half ($27). As a result, the nanny’s effective hourly rate for 50 hours is $19.80 (since overtime boosts the average). From the employer’s perspective, the overtime added roughly $5,400 to the gross annual wages (compared to if they somehow capped at 40 hours). It’s worth asking: would it be cheaper to hire two part-time nannies splitting the hours to avoid overtime? Possibly – but then you might incur duplicate fixed costs (two sets of unemployment taxes, maybe two workers’ comp policies or a higher premium for two employees, etc.). Many families in LA find one trusted nanny working longer hours is worth the overtime cost, but it’s important to go in with eyes open about those costs.

Comparing Scenarios: These case studies show how both schedule and hourly rate affect your total costs. Case 2 (45 hrs @ $20) and Case 3 (50 hrs @ $18) end up with similar annual costs in the mid-$50k range, even though one family is paying a higher hourly wage. The family with the lower hourly rate but more hours is paying for a lot of overtime. On the other hand, the family in Case 1 with a high hourly ($25) but low hours has a much lower overall cost (~$28k). When budgeting, you should forecast both the hours you’ll need and the pay rate, and remember to add roughly 10-15% for taxes and insurance. Also factor in things like a year-end bonus (which many families give – often one or two weeks’ pay as a holiday bonus), mileage reimbursement if the nanny drives the family car or their own for errands (the IRS mileage rate is ~$0.65/mile in 2025), and any benefits you provide (e.g. health stipend).

Conclusion and Tips for Nanny Employers

Legally employing a nanny in Los Angeles comes with significant responsibilities and costs beyond the paycheck. You need to account for employer taxes, overtime premiums, workers’ comp insurance, paid sick leave, and ensure you’re following all California and federal labor laws. The peace of mind of doing it right – and the benefits to your nanny (Social Security credits, unemployment safety net, etc.) – are well worth it, but it does require planning and budgeting.

Here are some final tips to manage the process:

By understanding these hidden costs of legal nanny payroll, you’re better equipped to be a fair and compliant employer. It may seem daunting at first – and yes, paying your nanny legally is more expensive than paying cash under the table – but it shields you from legal risks and provides your nanny with proper benefits and protections. In the long run, professionalism pays off. Your nanny will appreciate that you’re investing in their security (social security, unemployment, etc.), and you can rest easier knowing you won’t face nasty surprises like tax audits or injury liability. With careful planning and perhaps some professional help, you can successfully navigate nanny payroll in Los Angeles, giving your family quality care and your employee a legal, stable job.

Sources:

Questions about nanny pay

Frequently asked questions

What are guaranteed hours for a nanny?

Guaranteed hours mean your nanny is paid for an agreed minimum number of hours per week regardless of whether you use them. If you agree to 40 hours and only need 30 one week, you owe 40 hours of pay. California household employment law treats scheduled hours as wages owed.

Do I pay my nanny if I take a vacation?

If your nanny has guaranteed hours and you are not using them because you are traveling, you generally owe their guaranteed pay. If you negotiate a reduced vacation rate in advance and in writing, that may apply. Unilaterally not paying for weeks you are away is a wage violation.

Can I pay my nanny as an independent contractor?

No. In California, a household employee who works regular hours for one family is an employee, not an independent contractor. Misclassifying them as a contractor to avoid employer obligations creates retroactive tax liability and potential penalties.

Do I pay my nanny during holidays?

California does not legally require holiday pay, but paying for major holidays is standard in Los Angeles. Most work agreements list specific paid holidays. If your nanny works on a holiday, they should receive their regular pay plus any applicable overtime.

What are the real costs of hiring a nanny in Los Angeles?

Beyond hourly pay, expect: employer payroll taxes (roughly 10 to 12% of gross wages), paid sick leave (required by California law), 10 days paid vacation (competitive standard), and potentially a health contribution. Placement agency fees are typically 20% of first-year gross salary.

Los Angeles Nannies

15+ years placing nannies across Los Angeles

We help families find the right match quickly, with thorough screening, reference checks, and placement support from start to finish.

No hire within 30 days – your search fee is refunded.

Get a clearer nanny search plan

We help Los Angeles families define the role, understand pay, screen candidates, and move through the process with fewer surprises.

Scroll to Top