How to Keep a Great Nanny Once You Find One
There are many routes to go down to find your perfect nanny, and like your nanny is a unique asset to your family that reflects your household’s needs, so too will be the journey to find them.
Quick Answer
There are many routes to go down to find your perfect nanny, and like your nanny is a unique asset to your family that reflects your household’s needs, so too will be the journey to find them.
Quick Answer
The families who keep great nannies for years do three things consistently: they pay at or above market rate, they treat the nanny's time and boundaries with respect, and they communicate directly when something is not working rather than letting it build.
Pay Is Not Everything, But It Is the Foundation
You cannot retain a great nanny by being genuinely below market rate. In Los Angeles, great nannies know their value. Annual raises that at minimum match inflation (and ideally exceed it slightly) remove compensation as a reason to leave. One-time bonuses are appreciated but do not substitute for a living raise.
Schedule Stability Matters More Than Families Realize
Nannies build their lives around their schedule. Frequent last-minute changes, recurring late arrivals from parents, and unpredictable overtime are significant quality-of-life issues. If your schedule is genuinely variable, acknowledge this upfront and compensate for it. A nanny accepting a volatile schedule should be earning more than one with a fixed predictable one.
Scope Creep Is Quiet Turnover Risk
Asking your nanny to do more and more over time without adjusting compensation is one of the most common retention problems. It rarely feels significant in the moment -- just one more errand, just help with this one thing. Cumulatively it changes the role. When the nanny eventually leaves, families are often blindsided because they did not realize how much the job had expanded.
Recognition Does Not Have to Be Expensive
Being told specifically and genuinely that you appreciate them costs nothing. Most people in any job want to feel their work is seen. A nanny who hears "The kids are so much calmer since you started and we've noticed" is more loyal than one who receives a holiday bonus but never hears anything during the year.
The 90-Day and Annual Check-In
Structured check-ins create space for honest conversation before issues become problems. Ask what is working well, what could be better, and whether there is anything they need from you. Nannies rarely bring up concerns unprompted. Creating the space makes it safe to do so.
Frequently asked questions
How often should I give my nanny a raise?
Annual raises are standard. In Los Angeles, experienced nannies typically receive $1 to $2 per hour annually or 3 to 5% of their current rate. If their pay has fallen below market rate, a one-time adjustment to market followed by annual increments is appropriate.
What is the most common reason nannies leave?
Pay that has not kept pace with market rates, scope creep without compensation adjustment, consistent boundary violations like routine overtime or last-minute schedule changes, and feeling that their work is not acknowledged. Most of these are preventable.
How do I handle a disagreement with my nanny?
Address it directly and privately, as soon as possible. Be specific about the behavior you observed, not a character judgment. Most nannies respond well to direct, respectful feedback. Letting issues build without addressing them is the most common source of sudden resignations.
Should I give my nanny paid vacation?
California requires a minimum of 5 paid sick days per year. Paid vacation is not legally required but is standard for long-term placements in Los Angeles. Most families offer one to two weeks of paid vacation after one year. Accrued vacation must be paid out upon termination.
How do I prevent nanny burnout?
Define the role clearly, maintain reasonable and predictable hours, give advance notice for schedule changes, recognize good work specifically and regularly, and conduct structured check-ins where the nanny can raise concerns safely. Burnout builds slowly from accumulated small things, not one dramatic event.
What should I do if my nanny and child are not bonding?
Most children take two to four weeks to warm up to a new nanny. If there is no genuine connection by six weeks, have a direct conversation about what you are observing and what they can try differently. If the pattern continues, involve your placement agency before the guarantee window expires.
How do I keep a great nanny long-term?
Competitive pay, consistent communication, clear boundaries, and genuine appreciation are the biggest factors. Annual raises (3 to 5% is standard), acknowledging milestones, and giving adequate notice of schedule changes all contribute to long-term retention.
When should I give my nanny a raise?
Annually is the standard. A 3 to 5% increase is typical; more if their responsibilities have expanded or the market rate has moved. Cost of living in Los Angeles means staying competitive is important to retain experienced candidates.
What are the signs of nanny burnout?
Reduced engagement with the children, increased sick days, shorter communication, arriving late or leaving early. Burnout often stems from unclear expectations, insufficient breaks, or feeling undervalued. Early conversations usually resolve it before it becomes a resignation.
How do I handle disagreements with my nanny professionally?
Address issues directly and early rather than letting them build. Use a private setting, focus on specific behaviors not character, and listen to their perspective. Many families benefit from a written work agreement that covers expectations in advance.
Get a clearer nanny search plan
We help Los Angeles families define the role, understand pay, screen candidates, and move through the process with fewer surprises.